HedgeDoc - Collaborative markdown notes

<h1>Can ESAs Enter Restaurants? RealESALetter.com Review & Guide 2026</h1> No, emotional support animals are not allowed in restaurants under federal law. Unlike service dogs, ESAs have no public access rights to food establishments under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). This creates confusion because ESAs are protected in housing (Fair Housing Act) and previously had air travel protections. But restaurants operate under different legal frameworks: the ADA and FDA Food Code specifically exclude ESAs from dining establishments. ESAs provide comfort through presence alone, while service animals perform trained tasks. Restaurants can only accommodate animals trained for disability-related work due to health codes and food safety regulations. This comprehensive guide breaks down what the law says, when service dogs are allowed, and what to do if restaurants deny entry. For those seeking an <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/"> ESA Letter</a>, understanding where ESA protections apply helps navigate various situations appropriately. <h2>Why Restaurants Follow Different Rules Than Housing</h2> Restaurants are considered public accommodations, so they follow the ADA and local health codes, not housing laws. That's why ESA protections that apply at home don't automatically extend to dining spaces. Understanding this difference prevents confusion and helps individuals plan outings with realistic expectations. <h3>Understanding the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)</h3> The <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/ada-emotional-support-animal">ADA</a> is the primary federal law that governs access rights for people with disabilities in public accommodations, including restaurants. Under ADA regulations revised in 2010, a service animal is defined as a dog (and in limited cases, a miniature horse) that has been individually trained to perform specific tasks or work for a person with a disability. These tasks must be directly related to the person's disability. Key ADA provisions for restaurants: <ul> <li>Service dogs must be permitted in all areas where customers are normally allowed</li> <li>Restaurants cannot charge fees or require special deposits for service animals</li> <li>Staff may only ask two questions: (1) Is the animal required because of a disability? (2) What work or task has the animal been trained to perform?</li> <li>Staff cannot ask for documentation, demonstration of tasks, or details about the person's disability</li> </ul> The ADA does not cover emotional support animals because they provide comfort through their presence rather than performing specific trained tasks. This legal distinction is not a judgment on the value of ESAs; it simply reflects how federal access laws are structured. <h3>The Fair Housing Act and Air Carrier Access Act</h3> While ESAs lack access rights in restaurants, they do have legal protections in other contexts: <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/fair-housing-act-emotional-support-animal">Fair Housing Act (FHA)</a>: This law requires housing providers to make reasonable accommodations for ESAs, even in properties with no-pet policies. Landlords must allow ESAs without charging pet fees or deposits (though damage charges still apply). This protection applies to apartments, condos, college housing, and other residential settings. Air Carrier Access Act (ACAA): Until January 2021, airlines were required to accommodate ESAs in aircraft cabins. However, the Department of Transportation revised these rules, and airlines can now treat ESAs the same as regular pets. Most major carriers now require ESAs to travel in carriers and charge pet fees, though individual airline policies vary. These laws demonstrate that ESA protections are context-specific rather than universal. The same animal that must be accommodated in an apartment has no access rights in a restaurant. <h3>State and Local Health Department Regulations</h3> Beyond federal disability law, restaurants must comply with state and local health codes that restrict animals in food preparation and service areas due to sanitation concerns. Most jurisdictions' health regulations explicitly prohibit animals in restaurants except for: <ul> <li>Service animals as defined by the ADA</li> <li>Animals in outdoor dining areas (at the establishment's discretion)</li> <li>Working animals in agricultural or farm-to-table settings under specific conditions</li> </ul> These health codes exist to prevent contamination, control allergens, and maintain food safety standards. Even if a restaurant owner wanted to allow ESAs, doing so might violate their operating permits and health department approvals. Health department concerns include: <ul> <li>Animal dander and hair contamination</li> <li>Fecal matter and urine accidents</li> <li>Disease transmission vectors</li> <li>Allergen exposure for other patrons</li> <li>Behavioral unpredictability in crowded environments</li> </ul> Restaurant operators face potential fines, failed health inspections, or even temporary closure for violating these regulations. This creates a strong incentive to enforce animal policies strictly, regardless of the establishment's personal views on ESAs. <h2>What Restaurants Are Legally Required to Allow</h2> Restaurants must allow trained service animals that perform disability-related tasks, even if the disability isn't visible. ESAs, therapy animals, and pets do not fall under the same public access rules. This distinction between <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/emotional-support-animal-vs-service-animal">service animals and emotional support animals</a> helps restaurants stay compliant while maintaining food safety standards. Under the ADA, a service animal must meet three criteria: <ol> <li>Be a dog (or miniature horse in specific circumstances)</li> <li>Be individually trained to perform specific work or tasks</li> <li>Perform tasks directly related to a person's disability</li> </ol> Examples of service animal tasks: <ul> <li>Guiding people who are blind or have low vision</li> <li>Alerting people who are deaf or hard of hearing to sounds</li> <li>Pulling wheelchairs or providing mobility assistance</li> <li>Alerting to and protecting someone having a seizure</li> <li>Reminding someone to take medication at specific times</li> <li>Calming someone with PTSD during an anxiety attack through trained responses</li> <li>Detecting allergens in food for people with severe allergies</li> </ul> Public access rights: Service animals can accompany their handlers to virtually all public places, including restaurants, hotels, retail stores, medical facilities, transportation services, entertainment venues, and government buildings. The only legitimate reasons to exclude a service animal are if: <ul> <li>The animal is out of control and the handler cannot regain control</li> <li>The animal is not housebroken</li> <li>The animal poses a direct threat to health or safety that cannot be mitigated</li> </ul> <h3>Understanding Emotional Support Animals</h3> An ESA is an animal that provides therapeutic benefit through companionship and presence to a person with a mental or emotional disability. ESAs are prescribed by licensed mental health professionals but are not required to have any specific training. How ESAs differ from service animals: <ul> <li>Training: ESAs don't require specialized <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/emotional-support-dog-training">emotional support dog training</a>, while service animals must be trained to perform specific disability-related tasks</li> <li>Function: ESAs provide comfort through companionship; service animals perform disability-related work</li> <li>Species: ESAs can be any species (dogs, cats, birds, rabbits, etc.); service animals are limited to dogs and miniature horses</li> <li>Access rights: ESAs have housing and (formerly) airline protections; service animals have broad public access rights</li> <li>Documentation: ESAs require letters from licensed healthcare providers; service animals require no documentation</li> </ul> Where ESAs are protected: <ul> <li>Private housing under the Fair Housing Act</li> <li>College dormitories and campus housing</li> <li>Some workplace accommodations under case-by-case reasonable accommodation analysis</li> </ul> For students living on campus, understanding <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/community-college-esa-rights">community college ESA rights</a> helps navigate housing accommodation processes in educational settings. Where ESAs are NOT protected: <ul> <li>Restaurants and food service establishments</li> <li>Retail stores and shopping venues</li> <li>Hotels and public lodging (except as regular pets)</li> <li>Airlines (as of January 2021, treated as pets)</li> <li>Public transportation (no access rights)</li> <li>Entertainment and recreational facilities</li> </ul> While ESAs cannot accompany owners into restaurants, they remain protected in <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/pet-rent-for-esa">housing situations where pet rent for ESAs</a> should not be charged under Fair Housing Act provisions. <h3>The "Comfort vs. Task" Distinction</h3> The fundamental legal difference comes down to function. A service animal performs trained behaviors that mitigate disability-related limitations. An ESA provides emotional comfort simply by being present. Example scenario: Consider two veterans with PTSD: Veteran A has a service dog trained to: <ul> <li>Recognize signs of an impending panic attack</li> <li>Position itself between the veteran and other people in crowded spaces</li> <li>Apply deep pressure therapy during episodes</li> <li>Guide the veteran to exits when overwhelmed</li> </ul> This dog performs specific, trained tasks and qualifies as a service animal with restaurant access rights. Veteran B has an ESA dog that: <ul> <li>Provides companionship that reduces anxiety</li> <li>Offers comfort during difficult times</li> <li>Helps the veteran feel less isolated</li> </ul> This dog provides valuable emotional support but doesn't perform trained tasks. It qualifies as an ESA with housing protections but no restaurant access rights. Both animals are important to their handlers' wellbeing, but the law draws clear lines based on training and function rather than the severity of the disability or the value of the animal. <h3>Psychiatric Service Dogs: A Special Category</h3> It's important to note that <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/psychiatric-service-dog">psychiatric service dogs</a> are NOT the same as emotional support animals. Psychiatric service dogs are trained to perform specific tasks for people with mental health disabilities such as PTSD, severe anxiety disorders, or depression. These tasks might include interrupting self-harm behaviors, retrieving medication during panic attacks, or performing room searches to help someone with PTSD feel safe. Because they perform trained tasks, psychiatric service dogs have full public access rights, including in restaurants. <h3>Why This Distinction Matters for Restaurants</h3> Restaurant owners and staff need to understand these differences to: <ul> <li>Comply with ADA requirements for service animals</li> <li>Enforce health codes by excluding ESAs</li> <li>Avoid discrimination lawsuits from improper service animal denials</li> <li>Respond appropriately to access requests</li> </ul> ESA owners need to understand these differences to: <ul> <li>Have realistic expectations about access rights</li> <li>Avoid confrontations based on misunderstandings</li> <li>Plan dining experiences appropriately</li> <li>Explore legitimate alternatives and accommodations</li> </ul> <h2>How to Dine Out With an ESA Without Conflict</h2> Even though ESAs aren't allowed inside most restaurants, some locations may welcome animals in outdoor patio areas. The best approach is to call ahead, be transparent that the animal is an ESA, and follow any leash or seating rules. A respectful request is far more effective than arguing about access rights. Important considerations for outdoor dining: <ul> <li>Call ahead: Contact the restaurant before visiting to ask about their outdoor pet policy</li> <li>Be honest: Explain the animal is an ESA, not a service animal, and ask if they allow animals in outdoor areas</li> <li>Follow rules: If allowed, comply with all establishment requirements (leashes, specific areas, behavior expectations)</li> <li>Be prepared to leave: Understand the restaurant may still decline or ask the person to leave if the animal causes disturbances</li> <li>Respect other diners: Keep ESAs under control and minimize impact on other guests</li> </ul> Some restaurant chains and independent establishments have pet-friendly outdoor dining policies that welcome well-behaved animals. These businesses recognize that accommodating pets in outdoor spaces can be good for business while still complying with health regulations. <h3>Individual Restaurant Policies</h3> While federal law doesn't require ESA access, nothing prevents individual restaurants from choosing to allow ESAs as a customer service gesture (in outdoor areas or states with more flexible health codes). Factors influencing restaurant policies: <ul> <li>Local health department interpretation and enforcement</li> <li>Insurance and liability concerns</li> <li>Customer demographic and expectations</li> <li>Physical layout and space constraints</li> <li>Past experiences with animals in the establishment</li> </ul> How to approach restaurants about ESA accommodation: <ol> <li>Be upfront and honest: Explain the animal is an emotional support animal, not a service animal, and the legal distinctions are understood</li> <li>Ask, don't demand: "Do you have any pet-friendly outdoor seating options?" is more effective than asserting non-existent rights</li> <li>Highlight the animal's behavior: "My ESA is well-trained, calm, and won't disturb other guests" addresses the restaurant's main concerns</li> <li>Offer solutions: Suggest sitting in a specific area, visiting during less busy times, or other accommodations that address the establishment's concerns</li> <li>Accept the answer gracefully: If declined, thank them for considering the request and choose another establishment</li> </ol> <h3>What About "ESA Vests" and Online Certifications?</h3> The internet is filled with websites selling "official ESA registration," identification cards, and <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/emotional-support-dog-vest">vests</a> that supposedly grant public access rights. These are misleading at best and fraudulent at worst. Important truths: <ul> <li>No national ESA registry exists</li> <li>ESA vests and ID cards have no legal significance</li> <li>Legitimate ESAs require only a letter from a licensed mental health professional treating the individual</li> <li>Purchasing these items doesn't grant restaurant access rights</li> <li>Using them to claim service animal status is illegal in many states</li> </ul> Wearing an ESA vest in a restaurant doesn't change the animal's legal status. If questioned, individuals cannot legally claim ESAs are service animals, and restaurant staff trained in ADA compliance will know to ask about the tasks animals perform. To understand more about the difference between <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/real-vs-fake-esa-letter">real and fake ESA letters</a>, comprehensive guides are available. Legal consequences of misrepresentation: <ul> <li>Fines ranging from $100 to $1,000+ depending on the state</li> <li>Potential criminal charges for fraud</li> <li>Civil liability if animals cause harm or damage</li> <li>Undermining credibility of legitimate service animals</li> </ul> <h2>State-Specific Restaurant ESA Laws and Variations</h2> While federal law provides the baseline framework, states have enacted their own legislation that affects ESA access to restaurants. Many states have laws specifically prohibiting misrepresentation of ESAs as service animals. California: Penal Code Section 365.7 makes it a misdemeanor to fraudulently represent an animal as a service animal, with penalties up to $1,000 and six months in jail. Learn more about <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/california-esa-laws">California ESA laws</a>. Florida: State law (413.08) imposes a $500 fine and 30 hours of community service for falsely claiming an animal is a service animal. Review the complete <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/florida-esa-laws">Florida ESA laws</a> for more details. New York: Agriculture and Markets Law Section 118 prohibits false representation of service animals with penalties up to $100 for first offenses and $250 for subsequent violations. Check out <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/newyork-esa-laws">New York ESA laws</a> for comprehensive information. Texas: Health and Safety Code Section 121.006 makes impersonating a service animal handler a misdemeanor punishable by fines up to $300 and 30 hours of community service. Read about <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/texas-esa-laws">Texas ESA laws</a> to understand rights and responsibilities. Arkansas: House Bill 1420 introduced new requirements for ESA documentation, including a 30-day relationship requirement with mental health professionals. Learn more about <a href="https://telegra.ph/Arkansas-ESA-Law-HB-1420-New-30-Day-Requirement-Complete-Guide-02-06">Arkansas ESA law requirements</a> and how these state-specific regulations affect ESA letter validity. At least 30 states have similar laws protecting the integrity of service animal designations by penalizing fraudulent claims. <h3>States with More Flexible Interpretations</h3> A few states have considered or implemented laws that expand protections for ESAs beyond federal requirements, though these rarely extend to restaurant access: Illinois: While Illinois law generally follows federal ADA guidelines, some local ordinances in cities like Chicago have explored broader accommodations for assistance animals in certain contexts. Visit the <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/illinois-esa-laws">Illinois ESA laws</a> page for state-specific information. Colorado: State law recognizes multiple categories of assistance animals and has considered (though not fully implemented) expanded access provisions. Learn about <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/colorado-esa-laws">Colorado ESA laws</a> here. However, even in these states, restaurant access for ESAs remains limited due to health code considerations that supersede disability accommodation laws. Many states have enacted laws specifically prohibiting the misrepresentation of pets as service animals, with penalties including fines of $500 to $1,000 or more. Learn more about <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/fake-service-dogs-penalties">fake service dog penalties</a>. <h3>Local Health Department Variations</h3> County and city health departments have significant authority over food establishment regulations: Strict enforcement jurisdictions: Major metropolitan health departments (New York City, Los Angeles County, Chicago) typically enforce animal restrictions rigidly except for ADA-defined service animals. More flexible rural areas: Some smaller jurisdictions may have less stringent enforcement, particularly for outdoor dining spaces, though the law itself doesn't change. Pet-friendly municipalities: Cities like Portland, Seattle, and Austin with strong pet-culture often have more restaurants voluntarily welcoming animals in outdoor areas, but this reflects business choice rather than ESA legal rights. <h2>What to Do If a Restaurant Denies an ESA</h2> If a restaurant says no, staying calm and avoiding confrontation helps, as most denials are based on health code compliance. Asking if they have outdoor seating or if takeout is available provides alternatives. If someone feels they were treated unfairly due to their disability (not the ESA), documenting the interaction and following up through appropriate channels is recommended. What restaurants MUST do: <ul> <li>Allow legitimate service animals</li> <li>Not discriminate based on disability when the person is unaccompanied by any animal</li> <li>Provide equal service to all customers regardless of disability status</li> </ul> What restaurants DON'T have to do: <ul> <li>Allow emotional support animals inside dining areas</li> <li>Make exceptions to health code violations</li> <li>Accommodate animals that aren't trained service animals</li> </ul> What individuals SHOULD NOT do: <ul> <li>Claim ESAs are service animals</li> <li>Insist on rights that don't legally exist</li> <li>Cause confrontations or scenes</li> <li>Threaten legal action based on ESA denial</li> </ul> <h3>Productive Steps When Denied Access</h3> <ol> <li>Remain calm and respectful: Getting angry or confrontational won't change the legal reality and may result in being asked to leave entirely.</li> <li>Verify the denial is about the ESA specifically: Ask clarifying questions to ensure the issue is the animal, not disability discrimination.</li> <li>Inquire about alternatives: Ask about outdoor seating, takeout options, or specific times when accommodation might be possible.</li> <li>Educate politely (if appropriate): Some restaurant staff may genuinely not understand the difference between service animals and ESAs. A brief, non-confrontational explanation might help.</li> <li>Document the experience: If discrimination based on disability (rather than appropriate ESA denial) is believed to have occurred, note date, time, location, names of staff involved, and exact statements made.</li> <li>Consider filing feedback: Corporate customer service departments may appreciate feedback about customer experiences, even if the denial was legally appropriate.</li> </ol> <h3>When Denial Might Actually Be Discrimination</h3> In rare cases, what appears to be an ESA denial might actually be disability discrimination: Scenarios that may constitute actual discrimination: <ul> <li>Service is denied even when NOT accompanied by an animal</li> <li>Staff makes derogatory comments about disabilities</li> <li>Treatment differs from other customers in ways unrelated to the animal</li> <li>Intrusive questions are asked about disabilities when unaccompanied by any animal</li> </ul> If disability discrimination separate from the ESA access issue is believed to have occurred, options include: <ul> <li>Filing a complaint with the Department of Justice ADA Information Line</li> <li>Contacting state civil rights agencies</li> <li>Consulting with disability rights attorneys</li> </ul> <h2>Practical Guidance for ESA Owners Who Dine Out</h2> Planning outings like any accessibility need helps: research first, confirm policies, and keep backup options ready. Choosing pet-friendly patios when possible, or ordering takeout and enjoying meals in parks or at home with ESAs reduces stress while still allowing active social lifestyles. <h3>Before Going: Preparation Strategies</h3> Research extensively: Don't assume any restaurant will accommodate ESAs. Instead, call ahead, check websites, read reviews, and look for pet-friendly districts. Plan for alternatives: Always have backup plans including takeout options, comfortable places to dine with ESAs, and trusted friends who can pick up food. Be realistic about needs: Consider whether brief separations during meals are manageable, whether outdoor dining works in different weather, and whether ESAs can stay nearby safely. Time visits strategically: If restaurants allow outdoor animals, visit during off-peak hours, choose weather-appropriate times, and avoid peak rush periods. <h3>During Visits: Best Practices</h3> If restaurants allow ESAs in outdoor dining areas: <ol> <li>Arrive prepared with cleanup supplies, water, and ensure animals are clean and well-groomed</li> <li>Minimize impact on others by sitting away from busy walkways and preventing disruptive behavior</li> <li>Be ready to leave if needed if animals become distressed or disruptive</li> <li>Follow all establishment rules regarding designated areas, leashes, and size restrictions</li> </ol> <h3>Managing Separation Anxiety and Dining Without ESAs</h3> For many people, ESAs help manage anxiety—especially during social outings. If ESAs can't be brought inside, coping tools like grounding techniques, breathing exercises, and anxiety management apps can help during meals. Understanding how <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/emotional-support-animal-for-depression">ESAs help with depression</a> and anxiety provides context for why separation can be challenging. Some people also benefit from comfort reminders like photos or familiar items, and gradual exposure work with therapists can build confidence over time. For those experiencing acute anxiety symptoms, exploring <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/anxiety-alternative-treatments">anxiety alternative treatments</a> alongside ESA support creates comprehensive mental health management strategies. <h2>Common Misconceptions About ESA Restaurant Access</h2> Misinformation about emotional support animals abounds, particularly regarding where they can legally go. Addressing the most persistent myths helps clarify reality. Myth 1: "Paid ESA Registration Means Animals Can Go Anywhere" The Reality: No legitimate ESA registration system exists at the federal level. Learn more about <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/is-esa-registration-a-scam">ESA registration scams</a>. Myth 2: "ESA Vests Grant Restaurant Access" The Reality: Vests don't determine legal status. Using vests to misrepresent ESAs as service animals is illegal in many states. Myth 3: "Emotional Support Is a Task" The Reality: Simply providing comfort through companionship doesn't meet the ADA "task" requirement. Trained, specific actions are required for service animal classification. Myth 4: "Therapists Can Grant Public Access Rights" The Reality: Mental health professionals can prescribe ESAs for housing but cannot grant public access rights that don't exist in law. Myth 5: "Small ESAs Are Allowed But Larger Ones Aren't" The Reality: The issue isn't size—it's legal classification. All ESAs lack restaurant access rights regardless of size. Myth 6: "Panic Attacks Without ESAs Create Liability" The Reality: Restaurants are not legally liable for emotional responses to being separated from ESAs. Understanding whether <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/can-a-landlord-deny-an-esa">landlords can deny ESAs</a> shows similar principles apply in housing contexts where ESAs ARE protected. <h2>Understanding ESA Documentation and Rights</h2> Learning that emotional support animals aren't allowed in restaurants can feel discouraging, especially when ESAs support daily mental health. Still, understanding the law helps avoid stressful confrontations and plan dining experiences with confidence. The key takeaway is simple: the ADA gives public access rights only to trained service animals, not ESAs. ESAs are protected in housing under the Fair Housing Act, but restaurant rules are shaped by public accommodation laws and health codes. The best path forward is staying honest, calling ahead, and choosing ESA-friendly options like outdoor patios or takeout. Never misrepresent ESAs as service dogs, since it harms legitimate handlers and can lead to penalties. <h3>Obtaining Legitimate ESA Letters</h3> If legitimate ESA letters are needed or current letters need renewal, obtaining proper documentation is important for housing and contexts where ESAs are protected. Understanding <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/who-can-write-an-esa-letter">who can write ESA letters</a> is the first step. Services like RealESALetter.com connect individuals with licensed mental health professionals who can evaluate needs and provide appropriate ESA letters for housing accommodations. Learning <a href="https://www.realesaletter.com/blog/how-to-ask-doctor-for-emotional-support-animal">how to ask doctors for emotional support animals</a> helps those preferring to work with existing healthcare providers. Remember that legitimate ESA letters don't grant restaurant access, but they do ensure proper documentation for situations where ESAs are legally protected under Fair Housing Act provisions. <h2>Frequently Asked Questions</h2> <h3>Can ESA Dogs Be Brought to Restaurants With ESA Letters?</h3> No. Even with valid ESA letters, emotional support animals don't have restaurant access rights under the ADA. ESA letters apply to housing accommodations, not public places like restaurants. <h3>What's the Difference Between an Emotional Support Animal and a Psychiatric Service Dog?</h3> An ESA provides comfort through companionship and does not require task training. A psychiatric service dog is trained to perform specific tasks for a mental health disability, so it has full public access rights. <h3>Can Accommodations for Disabilities Be Requested Even Without ESAs in Restaurants?</h3> Yes. Reasonable accommodations like quieter seating, accessible tables, or other disability-related adjustments can be requested. However, restaurants still don't have to allow ESAs indoors. <h3>Are There Any Situations Where ESAs Must Be Allowed in Restaurants?</h3> No. Under current federal law, restaurants are not required to allow emotional support animals inside. Only trained service animals are protected for public access. <h3>Do Online ESA Registrations Give Animals Public Access Rights?</h3> No. Online ESA registrations, ID cards, and vests are not legally recognized and don't grant restaurant access. Legitimate ESA letters are mainly used for housing protections. <h3>Can Landlord ESA Approval Letters Be Used for Restaurant Access?</h3> No. Landlord approval only applies to housing under the Fair Housing Act. It does not give ESAs access rights in restaurants or other public places.